|
The TRUE process is a collaborative effort between the TRUE and Project Teams. The diagram on the left
illustrates the fundamental steps in TRUE.
The level of detail for a given TRUE depends on the needs of the client and on the time and
resources available.
The entire TRUE is typically conducted within a cooperative workshop environment. However, certain steps in
the process may be conducted more efficiently in smaller workgroups (i.e., a few people at a time),
depending on the technical expertise required to complete the task.
A description of each step in the process is listed below. The steps can also be viewed by placing the mouse
cursor over each box in the diagram.
- Review Project Plan:
- Review current approved scope, plans, and assumptions.
- Identify all the major project activities (e.g., environmental process, right-of-way
acquisition, design, construction phases) and their sequence in the form of a
comprehensive project flow chart. The project flowchart typically consists of
several tens of major project activities. Preliminary flow charts, which form the basis of existing estimates, may be
available as a starting point.
- Review Activity Base Costs and Durations. Estimate the most likely cost and
duration of each major activity if no major problems occur (i.e., “base” costs and
durations). Preliminary estimates of these costs and durations should already be
available and need to be reviewed. Also assess the uncertainty in these estimates
(e.g., 2/3 chance that the actual values will be within 10% of the most likely value).
- Develop Risk Registry: Identify all potential problems and opportunities
(collectively called “risk events”) that could lead to significant changes in cost or
duration for each project activity. Also identify the possible causes of such risk events
(e.g., a “fault tree”) and the possible subsequent outcomes that could follow from such
events (e.g., an “event tree”). For many problems, the fault and event trees may be greatly
simplified.
- Develop Cost and Schedule Uncertainty Model: Based on the project flowchart and
the risk registry, develop a computer model to evaluate the risk and uncertainty in total
project cost and schedule. Uncertainty in additional measures of interest (e.g., time to
completion of an important project milestone) can also be evaluated.
- Conduct Risk Assessment: Develop/assess the likelihoods and consequences of risks identified in the risk registry:
- Assess the Likelihoods: Based on expert interpretation of available
information regarding the possible causes of risk events, assess the likelihood of such
causes occurring. From these assessments, in conjunction with the fault trees,
determine the likelihood of each risk event occurring.
- Assess the Conditional Consequences: Assess the likelihood of possible
followon events occurring for each risk event, and the consequences (in terms of likely
additional cost and duration for various activities) if they do occur. From these
assessments, in conjunction with the event trees, determine the likely consequences for each
risk event, if it occurs.
- Evaluate Uncertainty in Cost and Schedule:
- Evaluate the Risks: Integrate over all activities and risk events, the “base”
costs and durations, and the likelihood and likely consequences of risk event occurrence,
to determine the uncertainty in actual project costs and schedule. This integration is
performed with an appropriate numerical model based on the project flowchart and the
assessed base and risk inputs.
- Identify the Critical Risks: Identify the most significant problems (i.e., those
which contribute the most to the “risk” cost or schedule) and identify possible ways to
reduce the risk associated with those problems (i.e., by either reducing their likelihood or
their consequences of occurrence).
- Evaluate Risk-Management Strategies: For critical risks and uncertainties, evaluate the
cost and duration to implement each risk management activity, and evaluate the benefits of
each risk management activity if implemented. Benefits are quantified in terms of likely
reduction in “risk” costs and durations, based on assessments of how much the likelihood or
consequences of occurrence of various problems would be reduced if the activity were
implemented. Possible changes in the cost/duration or benefits for a particular risk
management activity if it is conducted in combination with other risk management activities
(i.e., if complementary or competing) must be considered. Recommend those risk management
activities that are shown to be cost-effective (i.e., benefits exceed costs).
- Report Results: Typically in a presentation to the combined team (i.e., project team and the TRUE team), followed up with a written report.
|